When assessing the integrity of any financial instrument we deal with, I always return to first principles in biology, physics or finance to establish whether our actions are grounded on solid foundations.
From first principles, carbon as a commodity fulfils all the biological, physical and financial requirements for being traded as a commodity. This does not mean nature-based carbon is not complicated and problematic – it is, and these are the implementation issues we need to fix. Biodiversity meets none of these first principles to justify treating it as a commodity.
The UK’s Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and British Standards Institute have recently published the BSI Flex 702 standard. It’s a good standard for making a flawed instrument less dangerous. It’s not a convincing answer to the deeper question of whether biodiversity credits are the right instrument in the first place.
In fact the document confirms my argument: biodiversity credits require such extensive caveats, proxies, buffers, validation, verification, registries and governance controls because biodiversity does not naturally behave like a simple tradable unit. It treats the biodiversity credit model as the destination, rather than asking whether the model is conceptually right in the first place.
In my upcoming book ‘Goodbye Game Ranger’ there’s a table where I address the difference between an asset and a commodity and how this applies to carbon versus biodiversity.
The table shows biodiversity behaves more like an asset than a commodity: it supports ecosystem function, produces value over time, and should not be consumed as a compensatory unit in the way carbon credits are retired. Biodiversity credits will be an asset trapped in the body of a commodity, and better conservation finance would build asset value into landscapes and balance sheets rather than trying to force biodiversity into credit form.
The BSI standard acknowledges that loss is place specific and that offset credits should support the same local ecosystem, species community, or something “like-for-like or better.” That is a major concession that implicitly recognises the problem around the general commodification of biodiversity. If, as the BSI Flex standard states, biodiversity is highly local, context dependent and ecologically non-fungible, then it is not behaving like a commodity. It is behaving like a situated asset or a bundle of ecological qualities tied to a particular landscape.
With the onset of climate change and the need to protect the natural capital ecosystems that underpin over 60% of the world’s economic growth, we can’t simply commoditise the complexity of our natural ecosystems. However, considering nature the way the BSI Flex standard does means the biodiversity offset concept has a good chance of working, as implemented in the UK BNG programme and other good systems, such as the Australian biodiversity offset regulations.